The 1 best places to stay in Allegany (2026)

Ranked by real guest ratings across Allegany — only places with a solid number of reviews qualify.

1. 1
   Motel

   The New Lantern Motel★★

   4004 W State Rd Route 417, Allegany, NY 14706

   ★ 4.4 (179)

See all places to stay in Allegany →