Where to Rest

Hotels & places to stay in Butler Beach

83 places to stay in Butler Beach, FL ranked by guest rating and popularity.

About Butler Beach:Population 4,9511 m elevationAmerica/New York timeAir quality Moderate (US AQI 52)

Where to stay in Butler Beach

Butler Beach, Florida, has 44 places to stay listed on Where to Rest, mostly apartments. The most comfortable time to visit is generally March to May.

Among the highest-rated stays are Beacher's Lodge, Americas Best Value Inn Ocean Inn, and Ocean Gate Resort.

Compare live availability and prices for Butler Beach across our booking partner. We may earn a commission — it costs you nothing extra.

Check live prices in Butler Beach

Browse by type

The numbers

83 places to stay · 6 guest-rated · average 4.2

Popular filters

Showing 83 of 83

Festiva Resort, Resort in Butler BeachResort
Festiva Resort
125 Ocean Hibiscus Dr, St. Augustine, FL 32080
4.5 (15)
Beacher's Lodge, Hotel in Butler BeachHotel
Beacher's Lodge★★★
4.4 (1270)
BeachfrontPet friendlySwimming pool
Ocean Gate Resort, Resort in Butler BeachResort
Ocean Gate Resort
125 Ocean Hibiscus Dr, St. Augustine, FL 32080
4.3 (266)
BeachfrontSwimming pool
Hibiscus Oceanfront Resort, Hotel in Butler BeachHotel
Hibiscus Oceanfront Resort★★★
125 Ocean Hibiscus Dr, St Augustine Beach, FL 32080
4.1 (91)
Americas Best Value Inn Ocean Inn, Hotel in Butler BeachHotel
Americas Best Value Inn Ocean Inn
3955 A1A S, St. Augustine, FL 32080
4.0 (580)
BreakfastSwimming pool
St Augustine Beach & Tennis Resort, Hotel in Butler BeachHotel
St Augustine Beach & Tennis Resort
3960 A1A S, St. Augustine, FL 32080
3.9 (201)
Beachfront
Resort
Amagi Inn
Motel
America's Best Value Inn Ocean Inn
Serviced Apartment
Anastasia
Resort
Anastasia Condominium
Holiday Home
Atlantic Angel
Serviced Apartment
Atlantic East
Serviced Apartment
Barefoot Trace
Holiday Home
Barefoot Trace On-Site Rental Office
Lodge
Beachers Lodge
Serviced Apartment
Bella Mar
Holiday Home
Beso del Sol Beach Condo
Caravan Park
Bryn Mawr Ocean Resort
Serviced Apartment
Captains Quarters
Holiday Home
Chiquita's Sun House By Vacation Rental Pros
Serviced Apartment
Colony Reef Club
Resort
Colony Reef Club
Holiday Home
Coquina Condominiums, Unit B211, Crescent Beach
Holiday Home
Crescent Beach Vacation Condos
Serviced Apartment
Crescent Sandpiper
Motel
Cresent Silver Sands
Serviced Apartment
Creston House
Holiday Home
Creston House 11c By Vacation Rental Pros
Hotel
Devil's Elbow Fishing Resort
Bed & Breakfast
Dune Dreams
Lodge
Family Sun Vacation Rentals
Serviced Apartment
Four Winds Condominiums
Holiday Home
Fourwinds Condominium
Serviced Apartment
Hibiscus
Resort
Hibiscus 301-H By Vacation Rental Pros
Holiday Home
Hibiscus Condos
Serviced Apartment
Island House
Motel
Laquinta Inns
Resort
Matanzas River Project
Holiday Home
Mermaid's Castle
Serviced Apartment
Ocean Club
Holiday Home
Ocean Gallery Condos St Augustine
Hotel
Ocean Gallery Property Owners Association
Resort
Ocean Gallery Resort - St Augustine Beach
Caravan Park
Ocean Grove RV Resort
Resort
Ocean Grove RV Resort / EBB Tide
Serviced Apartment
Ocean House
Resort
Ocean House Condominium
Serviced Apartment
Ocean Sunrise
Serviced Apartment
Ocean Village Club
Resort
Ocean Village Club
Holiday Home
Ocean Village Club Rentals
Bed & Breakfast
Pearl of the Sea Luxury Bed & Breakfast
Serviced Apartment
Pelican Inlet
Resort
Pelican Roost
Caravan Park
Peppertree RV Resort
Serviced Apartment
Point Matanzas
Serviced Apartment
Saint Augustine Beach and Tennis Resort
Serviced Apartment
Sand Dollar Condominiums
Serviced Apartment
Sea Haven
Resort
Sea Place
Hotel
Sea Place
Hotel
Silver Sands St Augustine
Serviced Apartment
Spanish Trace
Holiday Home
Splendor at the Sea
Serviced Apartment
Spyglass Condominiums
Resort
Spyglass Resort Rentals
Resort
St Augustine Beach House
Holiday Home
St Augustine Beach Rentals
Holiday Home
Sugar Mongolia
Serviced Apartment
Summerhouse
Holiday Home
Summerhouse Beach & Racquet Club
Serviced Apartment
Sunset Harbor
Serviced Apartment
Tarpon Run Condominiums
Serviced Apartment
The Beach Club
Resort
The Beach Club at St. Augustine Beach
Serviced Apartment
The Coquina Condominiums
Serviced Apartment
The Ocean Gallery
Serviced Apartment
The Villas
Serviced Apartment
Tradewinds
Resort
Village Las Palmas 38
Resort
Villas Of Ocean Gate
Serviced Apartment
Windjammer

Weather in Butler Beach

Best time to visit: March to May — typically pleasant, with comfortable temperatures and less rain.

19°
11°
Jan
22°
14°
Feb
24°
15°
Mar
26°
18°
Apr
29°
20°
May
30°
23°
Jun
31°
24°
Jul
31°
24°
Aug
29°
24°
Sep
27°
22°
Oct
23°
17°
Nov
21°
13°
Dec

Max/min °C with monthly precipitation. Climate normals via Open-Meteo.

Daylight hours in Butler Beach

10.4h
Jan
11.1h
Feb
11.9h
Mar
12.9h
Apr
13.6h
May
14.0h
Jun
13.9h
Jul
13.3h
Aug
12.4h
Sep
11.5h
Oct
10.7h
Nov
10.2h
Dec

Daylight hours (15th of each month).

Other cities in United States

Staying in Butler Beach — FAQs

How many places to stay are there in Butler Beach?

There are 83 places to stay listed in Butler Beach on Where to Rest — hotels, motels, hostels, apartments and more, with photos, guest ratings, amenities and booking links.

Where is the best place to stay in Butler Beach?

Top-rated stays in Butler Beach include Amagi Inn, America's Best Value Inn Ocean Inn, Anastasia. See our ranked list of the best places to stay in Butler Beach.

Are there hotels with a pool in Butler Beach?

Yes — 3 places to stay have a swimming pool in Butler Beach. Use the "Swimming pool" filter to find them.

Are there pet-friendly places to stay in Butler Beach?

1 place to stay in Butler Beach welcomes pets. Use the "Pet friendly" filter to see them all.

Places to stay nearby

Cities like Butler Beach