Apartments & Holiday Homes in New Buffalo

26 apartments & holiday homes in New Buffalo, MI — with photos, guest ratings, amenities and booking links. Showing 1–26 of 26, ranked by review volume.

Compare live availability and prices for New Buffalo across our booking partner. We may earn a commission — it costs you nothing extra.

Check live prices in New Buffalo

All places to stay in New Buffalo Hotels (35)Guesthouses & B&Bs (16)Resorts & Lodges (22)

Bantam Brook Cottage

Beach Combers Vacation Rentals

Blue Fish Blue Heaven Vacation Rental

Blue Laguna Retreat

Bluefish Vacation Rental: Almost Heaven

Bow Tie Cottage

Cedar Hollow Cottage

Cek’s Retreat

Evergreen Cottage

Fiddlehead Cottage

Harbor Country Lodging & Vacation Rentals

Lake Michigan Vacation Rentals

Sounds Of Lake Michigan

Sun's Up, Bar's Down Rental

The Place to Be

The Sunset House

Yellow Bird Vacations

← All places to stay in New Buffalo