Where to Rest

The 3 best places to stay in Sag Harbor

Ranked by real guest ratings across Sag Harbor — only places with a solid number of reviews qualify.

Compare live availability and prices for Sag Harbor across our booking partner. We may earn a commission — it costs you nothing extra.

Check live prices in Sag Harbor
  1. 1
    Sag Harbor Inn, Hotel in Sag HarborHotel
    Sag Harbor Inn★★★
    45 West Water Street, Sag Harbor
    ★ 4.5 (135)
    Check live prices
  2. 2
    American Hotel, Hotel in Sag HarborHotel
    American Hotel
    45 Main Street, Sag Harbor
    ★ 4.4 (437)
    Check live prices
  3. 3
    Faraway Sag Harbor, Hotel in Sag HarborHotel
    Faraway Sag Harbor★★★
    31 W Water St, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
    ★ 3.8 (19)
    Swimming pool
    Check live prices

See all places to stay in Sag Harbor →