Where to Rest

Hotels & places to stay in Sag Harbor

5 places to stay in Sag Harbor, NY — ranked by guest rating and popularity.

About Sag Harbor:Population 2,2828 m elevationAmerica/New York time
⭐ Top 10 places to stay in Sag Harbor

Browse by type

Hotels
3 listed
Guesthouses & B&Bs
2 listed

Showing 5 of 5

Main Street Inn, Bed & Breakfast in Sag HarborBed & Breakfast
Main Street Inn
320 Main St, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
★ 5.0 (11)
Sag Harbor Inn, Hotel in Sag HarborHotel
Sag Harbor Inn★★★
45 West Water Street, Sag Harbor
★ 4.5 (135)
American Hotel, Hotel in Sag HarborHotel
American Hotel
45 Main Street, Sag Harbor
★ 4.4 (437)
Faraway Sag Harbor, Hotel in Sag HarborHotel
Faraway Sag Harbor★★★
31 W Water St, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
★ 3.8 (19)
Guesthouse
53 Lincoln St
53 Lincoln Street, Sag Harbor

Other cities in United States

Moab (451)Grand Marais (443)Times Square (383)Miami Beach (322)Estes Park (316)West Yellowstone (313)San Diego (301)Chinatown (282)

Staying in Sag Harbor — FAQs

How many places to stay are there in Sag Harbor?

There are 5 places to stay listed in Sag Harbor on Where to Rest — hotels, motels, hostels, apartments and more, with photos, guest ratings, amenities and booking links.

Where is the best place to stay in Sag Harbor?

Top-rated stays in Sag Harbor include 53 Lincoln St, American Hotel, Sag Harbor Inn. See our ranked list of the best places to stay in Sag Harbor.

Places to stay nearby

Bridgehampton (7) 7 kmShelter Island (4) 9 kmEast Hampton North (14) 9 kmWater Mill (5) 10 kmShelter Island Heights (15) 11 km