Luxury Hotels in Shelter Island Heights

1 place to stay in Shelter Island Heights, NY — ranked by guest rating, with photos, amenities and booking links.

All places to stay in Shelter Island Heights Pool (4)Spa (2)Pet-friendly (2)Parking (1)Breakfast included (3)

Sunset Beach Resort, Hotel in Shelter Island Heights

Sunset Beach Resort★★★

37 Shore Road, Shelter Island Heights

★ 4.1 (559)expensive

← All places to stay in Shelter Island Heights