Hotels & places to stay in Shelter Island Heights
27 places to stay in Shelter Island Heights, NY — ranked by guest rating and popularity.
Where to stay in Shelter Island Heights
Shelter Island Heights, in New York, has 15 places to stay listed on Where to Rest. The majority of these accommodations are hotels.
Among the highest-rated stays in the area are Sunset Beach Resort, The Pridwin Hotel & Cottages, and The Chequit.
Compare live availability and prices for Shelter Island Heights across our booking partner. We may earn a commission — it costs you nothing extra.
Check live prices in Shelter Island HeightsBrowse by type
The numbers
27 places to stay · 9 guest-rated · average 4.4★ — including 4 four-star hotels
Popular filters
Showing 27 of 27
Hotel
Bed & Breakfast
Hotel
Hotel
Hotel
Hotel
Hotel
Hotel
Bed & Breakfast
Motel
HotelDaylight hours in Shelter Island Heights
Daylight hours (15th of each month).
Other cities in United States
Staying in Shelter Island Heights — FAQs
How many places to stay are there in Shelter Island Heights?
There are 27 places to stay listed in Shelter Island Heights on Where to Rest — hotels, motels, hostels, apartments and more, with photos, guest ratings, amenities and booking links.
Where is the best place to stay in Shelter Island Heights?
Top-rated stays in Shelter Island Heights include Belle Crest Inn, Camp Liz - The Relaxation Station, Dering Harbor Inn. See our ranked list of the best places to stay in Shelter Island Heights.
Are there hotels with a pool in Shelter Island Heights?
Yes — 4 places to stay have a swimming pool in Shelter Island Heights. Use the "Swimming pool" filter to find them.
Are there pet-friendly places to stay in Shelter Island Heights?
2 places to stay in Shelter Island Heights welcome pets. Use the "Pet friendly" filter to see them all.