The 2 best places to stay in Shelter Island (2026)

Ranked by real guest ratings across Shelter Island — only places with a solid number of reviews qualify.

1. 1
   Bed & Breakfast

   Candle Lite Inn & Guest House

   3 S Ferry Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964

   ★ 4.9 (17)
2. 2
   Hotel

   Ram's Head Inn★★★

   118 South Ram Island Drive, Shelter Island

   ★ 4.4 (239)

See all places to stay in Shelter Island →