Hotels & places to stay in Shelter Island
9 places to stay in Shelter Island, NY — ranked by guest rating and popularity.
Where to stay in Shelter Island
Shelter Island, in NY, has 9 places to stay listed on Where to Rest, mostly guesthouses. Among the highest-rated stays are Ram's Head Inn, Candle Lite Inn & Guest House and Two South Ferry B&B.
Compare live availability and prices for Shelter Island across our booking partner. We may earn a commission — it costs you nothing extra.
Check live prices in Shelter IslandBrowse by type
Popular filters
Showing 9 of 9
Bed & Breakfast
Bed & Breakfast
Hotel
GuesthouseDaylight hours in Shelter Island
Daylight hours (15th of each month).
Other cities in United States
Staying in Shelter Island — FAQs
How many places to stay are there in Shelter Island?
There are 9 places to stay listed in Shelter Island on Where to Rest — hotels, motels, hostels, apartments and more, with photos, guest ratings, amenities and booking links.
Where is the best place to stay in Shelter Island?
Top-rated stays in Shelter Island include 2 South Ferry, 6 Conrad AirBnB, Austin"s Summer Retreat. See our ranked list of the best places to stay in Shelter Island.