Guesthouses & B&Bs in Shelter Island

3 guesthouses & b&bs in Shelter Island, NY — with photos, guest ratings, amenities and booking links. Showing 1–3 of 3, ranked by review volume.

Bed & Breakfast

Candle Lite Inn & Guest House

3 S Ferry Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964

★ 4.9 (17)

Bed & Breakfast

Two South Ferry B&B

2 South Ferry Road, Shelter Island

★ 4.8 (12)

Guesthouse

Azalea House

1 Thomas Avenue, Shelter Island

★ 3.2 (5)

← All places to stay in Shelter Island