Guesthouses & B&Bs in Shelter Island
6 guesthouses & b&bs in Shelter Island, NY — with photos, guest ratings, amenities and booking links. Showing 1–6 of 6, ranked by review volume.
Compare live availability and prices for Shelter Island across our booking partner. We may earn a commission — it costs you nothing extra.
Check live prices in Shelter Island
Bed & BreakfastCandle Lite Inn & Guest House
3 S Ferry Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
★ 4.9 (17)
Breakfast
Bed & BreakfastTwo South Ferry B&B
2 South Ferry Road, Shelter Island
★ 4.8 (12)
GuesthouseAzalea House
1 Thomas Avenue, Shelter Island
★ 3.2 (5)
Breakfast
Bed & Breakfast
2 South Ferry
Bed & Breakfast
Austin"s Summer Retreat
Bed & Breakfast
Fantabulous Abode